7 Comments
User's avatar
Judith Paulin's avatar

Well said Frank! Every point is a winning point in your argument!

Expand full comment
Frank Macskasy's avatar

Thanks, Judith.

National's track record on state housing is clear for everryone to see. Ironically, even former PM, John Key - raised in a state house - couldn't see the true value (social, not financial) of public housing for low income families and individuals.

I guess that's how deeply Nat's disdain for state housing is ingrained in their 'DNA', when it over-rides personal experience.

Expand full comment
Winston Moreton's avatar

I saw it happen.John Key campaigned on no asset sales. The devout family man BiilE laughed and said we have to balance the books Johnno. Key checked out

Expand full comment
Frank Macskasy's avatar

Yes, ditto, Winston. I heard the promises of no more asset sales... and then the sale/disposition of state houses began in earnest. It was a blatant broken promise. No wonder the Nats were chucked out in 2017.

And just in time, as a global viral pandemic loomed on the horizon...

Expand full comment
Mac Stevenson's avatar

Then the same BillE submitted a phoney review for Bishop that said sell more houses. Bishop also being a phoney agreed with the review because he and BillE had written it before the event. This is without question the most corrupt Govt in my lifetime.

Expand full comment
Frank Macskasy's avatar

I've read that report, Mac. It was bullsh*t from beginning to end, with a predetermined outcome clear from page 1. Its bias was clear when it became known that Kāinga Ora was never approached or consulted for their input!

https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/350460509/revealed-the-simple-texts-between-sir-bill-english-and-chris-bishop-that-led-to-k-inga-ora-review

https://theintegrityinstitute.substack.com/p/bill-englishs-housing-review-was

One of the main authors? Bill English. The same Bill English who oversaw the sale of approximately 6,000 state houses during his tenure as Finance Minister.

It boggles my mind that the media ever took the "report" seriously. There was very little questioning of it's impartiality. (Except Newsroom? Spinoff?)

Expand full comment
Mac Stevenson's avatar

Yes Frank it amazes me how much the MSM just looks the other way with so much this COC does and says.

Expand full comment